Home » Most Popular Candies

Most Popular Candies

Candy Pop Stars 

They’re popular for a reason! Our best-selling candies are beloved far and wide. Sweet, sour, rich, and bold, see why people can’t get enough of them. Find the familiar flavors of Hi-Chew, Maynards, Pop Rocks, Cadbury Mini Eggs, and so much more! Want to narrow the list down a bit more? Check out our Candyologist picks.

Filter products
The highest price is $299.99
$
$
Clear all

1851 Products

  • Crunchie Bar - Cadbury - Canadian Candy Bars

    Crunchie Bar - 44g

    $2.99
  • Charleston Chew Strawberry Candy Bar 2oz Opened, Charleston Chew, Charleston Chew Candy, Strawberry Chocolate Bar, Charleston Candy Bar, Charleston Chew Chocolate

    Charleston Chew - Strawberry Candy Bar - 2oz.

    $3.49
  • Smarties Mega Lollies -31g - Smarties Candy

    Smarties Mega Lollies -31g

    $0.89
  • Swedish Fish Blue Raspberry Lemonade - 3.59oz-Blue Raspberry-Swedish Fish-Gummies

    Swedish Fish Blue Raspberry Lemonade - 3.59oz

    $2.29
  • Jolly Rancher Gummies Sours Berries 182g Opened, Jolly Rancher, Sour Candy, Gummy Candy, Jolly Rancher Gummies

    Jolly Rancher Gummies Sours Berries - 182g

    $4.09
  • ✨Candyologist Pick✨
    Big Turk - Canadian Chocolate Bars - Big Turk Candy Bar is made in Canada by Nestle Chocolate - Candy from the 70s -Open Pack

    Big Turk - 60g

    $3.49
  • Aero Milk Chocolate Bubble Bar - Canadian Chocolate Bars

    Aero Milk Chocolate Bubble Bar - 42g

    $3.49
  • Oh Henry! Reese's Peanut Butter Bar 58g Opened - Oh Henry has been around since the 1920s

    Oh Henry! Reese's Peanut Butter Bar - 58g

    $2.99
  • Fun Dip Sour 3 Flavour Pack 39.6g USA Front, Fun Dip, Fun Dip Flavors, Sour Fun Dips

    Fun Dip Sour 3 Flavor Pack - 39.6g

    $2.49
  • Zotz Fizz Power Candy Strings-Cherry-Apple-Watermelon-Sour Candy-Zotz candy

    Zotz Fizz Power Candy Strings-Cherry-Apple-Watermelon

    $0.59
  • Cry Baby Nitro Sours Extra Sour Bubble Gum - 9-Ball Tube, Cry Baby Nitro Sours Extra Sour Bubble Gum, Intense burst of sourness, Sour explosion and taste adventure, cry baby bubble gum

    Cry Baby Nitro Sours Extra Sour Bubble Gum - 9-Ball Tube

    $2.99
  • Whatchamacallit Bar Opened, ​​whatchamacallit, whatchamacallit chocolate, whatchamacallit candy, retro chocolate

    Whatchamacallit Bar - 45g

    $1.89
  • Popeye Candy Sticks 16g, popeye candy sticks, popeye candy, retro candy, nostalgic candy, canadian candy

    Popeye Candy Sticks - 16g

    $0.59
  • Pop Rocks Original Cherry Popping Candy Open, pop rocks, pop rocks candy, cherry pop rocks, cherry candy, red candy, retro candy, classic candy

    Pop Rocks Original Cherry Popping Candy

    $1.39
  • Choward's Guava Tropical Candy Opened, Chowards, Tropical Candy, Chowards Candy

    Choward's Guava Tropical Candy

    $1.49
  • Chunky Chocolate Bar Opened, Chunky, Chunky Candy Bar, Chunky Candy, Chunky Chocolate, Chunky Chocolate Bar

    Chunky - 1.4oz

    $2.49
  • Nerds Candy Watermelon & Cherry 1.65 oz. Open, Nerds Candy Watermelon & Cherry, watermelon and cherry flavors, tangy, fruity, flavor party, jokes, chuckles, candy-lover, whimsy, snacking, sweet escape.

    Nerds Candy Watermelon & Cherry - 1.65 oz.

    $1.79
  • Bottle Caps Candy Theater Pack - 5ozBottle Caps Candy Theater Pack - 5oz, bottle caps candy, soda candy, soda bottle caps candy

    Bottle Caps Candy Theater Pack - 5oz

    $3.79
  • Mackintosh Toffee 45g Opened - Canadian Candy

    Mackintosh Toffee - 45g

    $3.49
  • Cow Tales Caramel Apple

    Cow Tales Caramel Apple

    $0.79
  • Candy Buttons - 0.5oz

    Candy Buttons - 0.5oz

    $1.49
  • 🏷️ Sweet Deal
    Sour Patch Kids - Sour Cherry Blasters 64g - Canadian Candy

    Sour Patch Kids - Sour Cherry Blasters 64g *BB Mar 12 2026*

    Sale$2.99 $1.49
  • Maynards Swedish Berries Candy - 154g

    Maynards Swedish Berries Candy - 154g

    $5.99
  • Charleston Chew - Vanilla Candy Bar - 65g

    Charleston Chew - Vanilla Candy Bar - 65g

    $3.49